[Shugo Event] Please let physical classes to be templars

[The Secret Cow Level]

Sweeping Hook:

• Effect 1: SkillATK_Instant (Physical attack skill)
  • 284 base damage
  • Inflicts "Pulled" status
• Effect 2: HostileUp (Enmity Incrase)
  • 30,000 effect2_reserved
• 15m range
• Fireball AoE with 8m radius, maximum 10 targets affected

Note: Most other event instance skills are of type NoReduceSpellATK_Instant, where they deal fixed damage (regardless of either side's stats) with fixed critical chances and damage multipliers.

However, for Sweeping Hook, this is regular physical damage skill (SkillATK_Instant). This skill is affected by physical attack, so please let physical classes take the Templar transformation. It is also affected by 10% forward movement damage bonus.

Chanter: 13,115 + 818 PvE Physical Attack

2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,419 damage on Grand Commander Gradi by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,383 damage on Intruder Sentinel by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,383 damage on Intruder Sentinel by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,382 damage on Intruder Lookout by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,383 damage on Intruder Challenger by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,383 damage on Intruder Challenger by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,383 damage on Intruder Gladiator by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,382 damage on Intruder Lookout by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 11:27:34 : You inflicted 8,383 damage on Intruder Sentinel by using Sweeping Hook. 

 

Spiritmaster: No physical attack

2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,247 damage on Grand Commander Gradi by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,211 damage on Intruder Sentinel by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,211 damage on Intruder Sentinel by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,211 damage on Intruder Sentinel by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,211 damage on Intruder Sentinel by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,211 damage on Intruder Guard by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,211 damage on Intruder Challenger by using Sweeping Hook. 
2019.05.13 10:42:55 : You inflicted 1,211 damage on Intruder Scrapper by using Sweeping Hook. 

 

[Rapier-DN]

You post some really helpful things usually but this time I will disagree with your solution. I would propose that the instance be class agnostic so that no one is at in unfair advantage or disadvantage. This way anyone could play any of the transforms with an equal chance- such as in IB.

[GenericUser25154]

57 minutes ago, Rapier-DN said:

You post some really helpful things usually but this time I will disagree with your solution. I would propose that the instance be class agnostic so that no one is at in unfair advantage or disadvantage. This way anyone could play any of the transforms with an equal chance- such as in IB.

He is not suggesting a change, he is simply giving a tip on how things work right now!

[The Secret Cow Level]

I think the thread title wasn't worded very well. If I could rename the thread right now then I would name it as "[Shugo Event] Damage from Templar's pull skill is affected by physical attack stat"

A proper solution to make this skill class agnostic would be reduce the damage of SkillATK_Instant portion to 1, and add a new effect of type NoReduceSpellATK_Instant that is responsible for almost all of the damage. But this change will have to be done by the devs in Korea - NCWest cannot do this on their own.